My 11yo got a C on a math test yesterday and I immediately felt like I messed up somehow. He studied, I helped him study, but apparently not enough? I know it's not my test but it's hard not to feel responsible. Is this normal or am I being insane? How do other dads handle this without spiraling?
Real talk: if he didn't study at all and failed, THEN you might have a parenting problem. But he studied and got a middling grade? That's just... being a kid who's still figuring out how to study. It's data, not a referendum on you.
I had to tell myself this same thing after my kid's soccer season where he sat the bench most games. Like, I felt like a failure for not training him enough, for picking a team that wasn't perfect, for everything. Then I realized he was having fun and learning, which was the whole point. Same energy as your C—you're not failing, he's learning.
The fact that you helped him study and he STILL got a C actually means something important happened—he learned that putting in effort doesn't guarantee perfect results. That's a real life lesson. C on a test beats perfect grades and zero resilience any day.
One C doesn't mean you messed up. If this becomes a pattern, then you pivot strategy. But one test? That's just part of learning. Your kid's gonna remember that you helped him, not that he got a C.
You know what's wild? My kid's teacher told me kids who struggle a little do better long term than kids who coast. A C might be the best thing that happened to him - he'll figure out what he needs to do differently next time.
This hits different as a parent vs as a student. You're feeling the C but he's learning that one bad test doesn't define him. That's actually the win here - he studied, showed up, and learned something. Hard to fail at that.
I wonder if you're also being hard on yourself because math was tough for you? I noticed I was way more stressed about my son's grades when they were in subjects I struggled with. Might be worth digging into where this feeling actually comes from.
The fact that you helped him study and he didn't ace it... welcome to the part where you realize you can't control outcomes, only effort. Sounds like he did the effort part. The C is just information for next time.
Man I feel this in my bones. My therapist told me I'm confusing his failures with my failures and it broke me a little. Your kid got a C. Not a C in life - a C on one test. That's data, not judgment on you.
Sign in to join the conversation.
This is SO normal and you're not alone in it. I felt the same way when my 10yo got a D in science. Took me days to realize... he's 10. A C is totally fine. You helped him study, he put in effort, life happened. That's literally the goal.
The guilt trap is real man. Took me until kid #3 to understand that one bad test grade says absolutely nothing about my parenting. You studied together. He learned the material enough to get a C. That's... that's actually pretty solid at 11.