My kids finally groaned at my jokes
Today my son rolled his eyes when I said 'I'm not saying I invented the Dad joke, but I was there when the first one was born.' This is the happiest moment of my life. My 9 year old finally gets annoyed by my humor instead of laughing at everything. I've made it to Peak Dad status.
The first eye roll is bittersweet. You're so proud that your jokes are bad enough to warrant an eye roll. Mission accomplished.